How Does Vinyl Flooring Compare to Ceramic Tile?

Dale Devries

Vinyl flooring is a soft sheet or tile made of vinyl that attaches to your underlayment with some type of adhesive. There are hundreds of designs for vinyl flooring so you are sure to find one to match your room. Vinyl flooring is easy to install and clean making it a very popular flooring used in homes today.

How Does Vinyl Flooring Compare to Ceramic Tile?

Vinyl Flooring

It is also the least expensive of the common flooring types of tile, wood and laminates. There are different types of vinyl flooring. A full spread vinyl floor needs adhesive troweled on under the entire floor. Vinyl tiles commonly are self-adhesive, meaning the adhesive is already on the tile and you use water or another agent to release it. Quickly becoming the most popular is the sheet vinyl that uses a perimeter adhesive. It is easier to install and you can take it up without all the trouble of the full adhesive if you want to put a different kind of flooring down later. Vinyl flooring also comes in a variety of softness, style and quality.

Tile Flooring

Ceramic tile flooring comes in many different patterns and various sizes. Depending on the size of the room, certain sized tiles look better. Tiling a floor is a permanent solution to flooring. When figuring the cost of tiling the tile itself is only a fraction. You must consider the backer board, thinset, grout and sealers. To cut the tile to fit in a room properly you will need a wet saw too. These are a little expensive if you're only going to use it once but they can be rented at the local tool rental store. Ceramic tile is very easy to maintain and is one of the most durable flooring solutions there are. You can use it in any room and it's not affected by moisture as with other flooring materials.

Vinyl Flooring vs. Ceramic Tile

Both vinyl and ceramic tile are very durable but tile will take more of a beating. Broken glass won't hurt a tile floor but can put a gouge in vinyl. When it comes to foot comfort, vinyl wins the battle. Tile is cold and hard to stand on for any length of time where vinyl in warmer and made to be soft for the feet. However, a throw rug can remedy the tiles hardness and coldness. Tile stays looking great longer than vinyl does. Vinyl has a tendency to yellow and shows wear and tear sooner than tile does. Tile is more expensive than vinyl and much harder to install. So for the do-it-yourselfer, the easier job would definitely be the vinyl. For most people, it's just a matter of budget or preference.