Pros & Cons of Power Vents in the Roof

Attic ventilation removes hot air from the space between the living area and the roof of the home.

Noise

This ventilation can be passive or powered. Passive ventilation includes vents at the ridge or peak of the roof, coupled with vents at the soffits under the eaves. The rising hot air exits the ridge vent, with fresh air entering the soffit vents. Powered vents use electrically powered fans to blow air out of the attic. This air is replaced with fresh air entering through other, nonpowered vents. Both methods have pros and cons.

Powered roof vents make noise, though the amount of fan noise that can be heard indoors is tempered by the home's insulation and building materials, and varies from house to house. Thermostats control the fan operation, usually operating the fan when the attic temperature is above 100 degrees. This can extend into the evening in warmer climates, resulting in fans that operate when the family is trying to sleep.

Costs

Passive vents are simple weatherproof grills or covers with no moving parts, whereas power vents include an electric motor and blower or fan assembly, producing a higher cost. The fans are heavier than passive vents and require more installation time. Special electrical lines to the attic insulation may also be required for power vents, adding to the installation cost.

Energy Use

Electric power vents consume about 300 watts of electricity while operating--though actual run time determines the exact cost of operation--but the proper ventilation of the attic should reduce air conditioning costs, ultimately saving you money. In addition, solar-powered power vents are available, while passive attic vents utilize no energy.

Mechanical Failure

Attic power vents are mechanical devices with moving and electrical parts, so failure is possible. Passive attic vents have no moving or electrical parts, and thus have no potential for failure that can result in additional repair or replacement costs.

About the Author

Keith Allen, a 1979 graduate of Valley City State College, has worked at a variety of jobs including computer operator, medical clinic manager, radio talk show host and potato sorter. For over five years he has worked as a newspaper reporter and historic researcher. His works have appeared in regional newspapers in North Dakota and in "North Dakota Horizons" and "Cowboys and Indians" magazines.