Disadvantages of Mechanical Fasteners
The advantages of fasteners, by nature, are relative to whatever you're comparing them to. There are many categories and types of fasteners. There are even many types of mechanical fasteners, but most mechanical fasteners rely on friction and tension to create a mechanical bond, as in a nut and bolt. Disadvantages to mechanical fasteners are often seen in applications that use other types of fastening systems.
Mechanical connections such as nut and bolt applications and heavy machine screws can be incredibly strong connections. However, they are intrinsically weaker than continuous metal. Compare it to a welded joint. Molten steel, for example, coalesces into one continuous piece. There are no threads to strip. Vibration cannot loosen it, and stress is less likely to break a properly executed weld than a bolt.
Difficulty of Refastening
A benefit of mechanical fasteners is the ability to be fastened, then refastened. This can be a drawback, too -- particularly for some kinds of mechanical fasteners. Engines, for example, are full of bolts that are time consuming to remove and retorque. Although, other mechanical fasteners, such as the buckles found on ski boots, can expedite fastening and refastening.
Most mechanical fasteners are very precise, usually consisting of a machine-threaded cylinder and machine-threaded bolt-shaft. This is a drawback when you need a more "approximate" connection. For example, many motorcycle tank bags use powerful magnets. The magnets let you set the tank bag on the tank and it holds it firmly, wherever you place it, but not so firmly you can't pull it off with a little tug.
The temporary mating of metal surfaces -- in spite of a precision fit -- is still vulnerable to corrosion, most often iron oxide, commonly known as rust. There's little use in having a temporary mechanical connection if it becomes permanently rusted together. If it happens, you lose the benefits of the mechanical connection, without the advantages of a welded or other kind of connection.
John Willis founded a publishing company in 1993, co-writing and publishing guidebooks in Portland, OR. His articles have appeared in national publications, including the "Wall Street Journal." With expertise in marketing, publishing, advertising and public relations, John has founded four writing-related ventures. He studied economics, art and writing at Portland State University and the Pacific Northwest College of Art.
- Hemera Technologies/AbleStock.com/Getty Images