Step 1
Turn off the water supply to the shower at the water mains in the basement or by the street.
Step 2
Remove the cover from the diverter knob with a flat screwdriver.
Step 3
Remove the screw from the center of the diverter knob. Pull out on the diverter knob.
Step 4
Turn the bolt coming out of the center of the diverter counterclockwise with a wrench to remove it.
Step 5
Insert a cartridge puller, available from hardware stores, into the diverter valve. Tighten the handle until the puller is attached to the cartridge. Tug on the cartridge puller with a wrench to remove it from the wall.
Step 6
Insert the new diverter into the wall. Replace the bolt in the center, as well as the handle. Turn on the water and test.